Skip to content

Inside the product

Compare options.
Review the evidence.

Use shared criteria to evaluate projects, use cases, vendors or interview evidence.

Keep scores, sources and review questions together. Adapt a template to the evaluation your team needs to run.

Find your evaluation template
Worked example · Use-case evaluationChoosing a pilot projectIllustrative data throughout
Set criteria and priorities

Decide how to
compare the options.

Agree on impact, data readiness, delivery feasibility and value for effort. Give each criterion a weight to show its importance.

For example, a short deadline may make delivery feasibility more important than potential impact.

Try changing a priority
Sample decisionExample / Use-case evaluation

Choose our next pilot

Compare three initiatives using four criteria. Change the priorities to see how the ranking responds.

Weighted decision matrix Illustrative data · scores out of 10
CriterionWeightKnowledge searchRequest triageProcess guide
Expected impact30%9.06.07.0
Data readiness28%7.08.07.0
Delivery feasibility24.5%6.09.07.0
Value for effort17.5%6.08.07.0
Weighted score/ 107.187.647.00
Leading option at 30% impact weightRequest triage 7.64 / 10

Request triage’s readiness and feasibility scores outweigh its lower impact score.

Try changing the priorities
Review the evidence

Check what supports
each score.

An 8 out of 10 is someone’s judgment. Attach the source behind it, ask what’s missing, and let a colleague check it. A linked source and a verified judgment are different things.

Start with your own question
Data readiness · Request triage8 / 10
“Eight of ten sampled request types have complete routing data.”

Sample source excerpt

Which requests were sampled?

Check whether the sample covers the requests expected in the pilot.

Example review question · still open

Keep the question with the score. Pick it up when the answer arrives.

Save the evaluation

Save the result
and its reasoning.

Save the options, priorities and reasoning behind your choice. When someone revisits the decision, they can see what you knew at the time.

Read a sample decision record

For a closer look

Explore the features.

Open a section for the details. You don’t need to learn every method to start.

Create your evaluation

Start with a template. Change the parts that don’t fit.

Choose a template